Hey PD you don't seem to post nearly as much as you used to, are people covering up their outdoor sockets?
I am slightly surprised to see that many best game entries on this topic have been quite modern. Maybe one day I should conduct an age poll, or are old games really that unexciting? Even my favourite game SMW does not quite fit into the classic status yet, still too new; but believe me it will.
CSOTN is an absolutely brilliant game, I was quite amused by the first ending where upon the world turns upside down and it all needs to be completed again with harder enemies, quite a brilliant touch.
I would urge you all to buy the game, and I would burn it to multiple CD's but my CDRW is a piece of shit that doesn't work. Some of you may not know that this is not a typical whip 'n slash Castlevania game but an action RPG that has the best power up system I have ever seen (I am sorry but Metroid never really hit the right buttons for me).
The music, voice acting, graphics (yes they are 2D, but watch out for the massive sprites and backgrounds) and gameplay make me wonder why SMW beat it...oh yeah I remember now, it has the best levels ever created.
I have never played the Saturn version, though now I am tempted to search for it; what does this timeline thing do anyway?